How to Avoid a Medicare Set-Aside: Tips for Managing Your Medical Expenses
According to the Medicare Secondary Payer Act, individuals who receive settlements from liability or workers’ compensation claims must set aside a portion of their funds to cover future medical expenses that Medicare would otherwise pay for. This is known as a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA). Failing to properly establish an MSA can result in serious legal and financial consequences. However, it is possible to avoid an MSA altogether in certain situations.

To avoid an MSA, it is important to first understand when it is required. An MSA is necessary when a settlement includes compensation for future medical expenses related to the injury for which the settlement was awarded. If the settlement does not include compensation for future medical expenses, an MSA is not required. Additionally, if the individual is not a Medicare beneficiary at the time of settlement or does not anticipate becoming one within 30 months, an MSA is not necessary.
Preventing an unnecessary MSA may also be possible by negotiating the settlement agreement to exclude future medical expenses or by utilizing alternative funding sources for future medical expenses. However, it is important to consult with an experienced attorney or Medicare Set-Aside consultant to ensure compliance with Medicare regulations and avoid potential legal issues.
Key Takeaways
- Understanding when an MSA is required is crucial to avoiding unnecessary expenses and legal complications.
- Negotiating the settlement agreement or identifying alternative funding sources may help prevent the need for an MSA.
- Consulting with an experienced attorney or Medicare Set-Aside consultant can provide valuable guidance and ensure compliance with Medicare regulations.
Table of Contents
Understanding Medicare Set-Aside

A Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) is a financial arrangement that is designed to allocate a portion of a settlement or judgment for future medical expenses related to a workers’ compensation or personal injury claim. The purpose of an MSA is to protect Medicare’s interests by ensuring that the settlement funds are used to pay for the claimant’s medical expenses before Medicare pays for any related treatment.
MSAs are typically funded with a lump sum payment, but they can also be funded with a structured settlement. However, it is not advisable to fund an MSA with a structured settlement because the monies are not readily available to pay for medical expenses.
It is important to note that not all workers’ compensation or personal injury settlements require an MSA. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) require an MSA when the settlement is for a workers’ compensation claim and the claimant is a Medicare beneficiary, or when the settlement is for a personal injury claim and the claimant reasonably expects to become a Medicare beneficiary within 30 months of the settlement date.
The MSA must be reviewed and approved by the CMS before the settlement can be finalized. The CMS reviews the MSA to ensure that the allocation is reasonable and that the funds will be used only for related medical expenses. The CMS also requires that the MSA be administered by a professional administrator who is responsible for disbursing the funds for approved medical expenses and reporting to the CMS on the use of the funds.
In summary, an MSA is a financial arrangement that is designed to allocate a portion of a settlement or judgment for future medical expenses related to a workers’ compensation or personal injury claim. It is important to understand when an MSA is required and to ensure that the MSA is reviewed and approved by the CMS before the settlement can be finalized.
Identifying Potential Medicare Set-Aside Scenarios

A Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) is an amount of money set aside from a settlement or judgment to cover future medical expenses for a Medicare beneficiary. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) requires an MSA in certain situations to protect Medicare’s interests. However, not all settlements or judgments require an MSA. Here are some scenarios that may trigger the need for an MSA:
Workers’ Compensation Settlements
If the settlement or judgment involves a workers’ compensation claim and the injured party is a Medicare beneficiary or is likely to become one within 30 months of the settlement or judgment, an MSA may be required. The MSA should cover future medical expenses related to the work injury that would otherwise be covered by Medicare.
Liability Settlements
If the settlement or judgment involves a liability claim and the injured party is a Medicare beneficiary or is likely to become one within 30 months of the settlement or judgment, an MSA may be required if the settlement or judgment includes damages for future medical expenses. The MSA should cover future medical expenses that would otherwise be covered by Medicare.
Conditional Payment Situations
If Medicare made conditional payments for medical expenses related to the settlement or judgment, an MSA may be required to reimburse Medicare for those payments. An MSA can protect the beneficiary from having to pay back Medicare out of their own pocket.
Medicare Advantage Plans
If the injured party is enrolled in a Medicare Advantage Plan, an MSA may be required. The MSA should cover future medical expenses that would otherwise be covered by the Medicare Advantage Plan.
It is important to note that not all settlements or judgments in these scenarios require an MSA. An MSA is only required when the settlement or judgment meets certain criteria. It is recommended to consult with a qualified attorney or settlement consultant to determine if an MSA is necessary in a specific case.
Preventing Unnecessary Medicare Set-Aside

When it comes to avoiding a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA), early resolution of claims is key. The longer a claim remains open, the higher the risk of Medicare making payments for related medical expenses. By resolving claims quickly, beneficiaries can avoid the need for a Medicare Set-Aside altogether.
Another effective strategy for avoiding an MSA is to make effective use of insurance. Insurance policies can provide coverage for medical expenses related to a claim, reducing the need for Medicare to make payments. By maximizing the use of insurance, beneficiaries can reduce the amount of money that needs to be set aside for future medical expenses.
Professional administration services can also be used to prevent unnecessary Medicare Set-Asides. These services can help ensure that medical expenses related to a claim are properly documented and that all necessary information is provided to Medicare. By working with a professional administration service, beneficiaries can avoid the need for an MSA and ensure that Medicare’s interests are protected.
Early Resolution of Claims
Resolving claims early is critical to avoiding the need for a Medicare Set-Aside. By resolving claims quickly, beneficiaries can reduce the risk of Medicare making payments for related medical expenses. This can be achieved through a variety of strategies, including early settlement negotiations and alternative dispute resolution methods.
Effective Use of Insurance
Insurance policies can provide coverage for medical expenses related to a claim, reducing the need for Medicare to make payments. By maximizing the use of insurance, beneficiaries can reduce the amount of money that needs to be set aside for future medical expenses. This can be achieved through a variety of strategies, including negotiating with insurance providers and exploring alternative insurance options.
Professional Administration Services
Professional administration services can help ensure that medical expenses related to a claim are properly documented and that all necessary information is provided to Medicare. By working with a professional administration service, beneficiaries can avoid the need for an MSA and ensure that Medicare’s interests are protected. These services can include medical case management, medical cost projection, and Medicare Set-Aside allocation.
Legal Implications of Avoiding Medicare Set-Aside

Avoiding a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) can have significant legal implications. While it may seem like a good idea to avoid the cost and hassle of setting up an MSA, doing so can lead to serious consequences.
First and foremost, avoiding an MSA can result in a violation of the Medicare Secondary Payer (MSP) statute. The MSP requires that Medicare be a secondary payer to any other insurance or settlement funds. If a settlement is reached without taking into account future Medicare costs, it can lead to a violation of the MSP statute.
In addition to violating the MSP statute, avoiding an MSA can also lead to potential liability for the plaintiff’s attorney. If a plaintiff’s attorney advises their client to avoid setting up an MSA and Medicare later discovers that the settlement did not take into account future medical expenses, the attorney may be held liable for any unpaid Medicare expenses.
Avoiding an MSA can also lead to complications in the settlement process. If Medicare later discovers that a settlement did not take into account future medical expenses, they may refuse to cover any related medical expenses until the settlement funds are exhausted.
Overall, avoiding an MSA may seem like a good idea to save time and money, but it can have serious legal implications. It’s important to work with an experienced attorney who can guide you through the MSA process and ensure that all legal requirements are met.
Role of Medicare Set-Aside Consultants

Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) consultants are professionals who specialize in analyzing medical and legal records to determine the future medical expenses that will be required for an injured individual. These consultants are usually hired by attorneys, insurance companies, or claimants themselves in order to ensure that the settlement amount is appropriate and that the future medical expenses are adequately addressed.
MSA consultants are responsible for preparing a proposal that outlines the estimated future medical expenses of the injured person. This proposal is then submitted to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) for review and approval. The CMS review process ensures that the proposed settlement amount is reasonable and that the future medical expenses are adequately addressed.
MSA consultants are also responsible for ensuring that the injured person’s medical records are up to date and that all of the relevant medical information is included in the proposal. This includes information about the individual’s medical history, current medical condition, and any ongoing treatment that is required.
It is important to note that MSA consultants are not required by law and their services are not always necessary. However, in cases where the future medical expenses are significant, hiring an MSA consultant can be beneficial. MSA consultants can help ensure that the settlement amount is appropriate and that the injured person’s future medical expenses are adequately addressed.
Conclusion

Avoiding a Medicare Set-Aside (MSA) can be a complex process, but it is possible with careful planning and execution. While it is important to consider the potential consequences of not setting aside funds for future medical expenses, there are several strategies that can be employed to minimize or eliminate the need for an MSA.
One approach is to structure the settlement agreement in a way that does not explicitly allocate funds for future medical expenses. Instead, the settlement can be structured to provide a lump sum payment that covers all damages, including medical expenses, without specifying how those funds will be used. This approach can be effective in cases where the claimant has private health insurance or is eligible for Medicaid, which can cover future medical expenses.
Another strategy is to negotiate with Medicare to waive the requirement for an MSA. This can be done by demonstrating that the settlement amount is insufficient to cover both the claimant’s past medical expenses and future medical expenses. In some cases, Medicare may agree to waive the MSA requirement if the claimant agrees to repay Medicare for any future medical expenses related to the injury.
Finally, it may be possible to use a Medicare Set-Aside Trust (MSAT) to avoid the need for an MSA. An MSAT is a trust account that is established to hold funds for future medical expenses related to the injury. The funds in the account are managed by a trustee and can be used to pay for medical expenses as they arise. By using an MSAT, the claimant can avoid the need for an MSA and ensure that their future medical expenses are covered.
Overall, avoiding a Medicare Set-Aside can be challenging, but it is possible with careful planning and execution. By considering all of the available options and working with experienced legal and financial professionals, claimants can minimize the impact of an MSA on their settlement and ensure that their future medical expenses are covered.
Frequently Asked Questions

What are some alternatives to a Medicare Set Aside?
There are several alternatives to a Medicare Set Aside, such as a lump-sum settlement, structured settlement, or annuity. A lump-sum settlement is a one-time payment made to the claimant in exchange for releasing the defendant from liability. A structured settlement is a series of payments made over time. An annuity is a financial product that provides a steady stream of income.
What are the requirements for a Medicare Set Aside?
The requirements for a Medicare Set Aside include determining the amount of money that will be needed to cover future medical expenses related to the injury, obtaining approval from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), and setting up a trust account to hold the funds.
What is the process for creating a Medicare Set Aside?
The process for creating a Medicare Set Aside involves gathering medical records and bills, obtaining a life care plan, determining the amount of money needed to cover future medical expenses, submitting the proposed set-aside amount to CMS for approval, and setting up a trust account to hold the funds.
What are some common mistakes to avoid with a Medicare Set Aside?
Some common mistakes to avoid with a Medicare Set Aside include underestimating future medical expenses, failing to obtain CMS approval, and failing to set up a trust account to hold the funds. It is important to work with an experienced attorney and professional administrator to avoid these mistakes.
What happens if I don’t set up a Medicare Set Aside?
If you do not set up a Medicare Set Aside, you risk having Medicare refuse to pay for future medical expenses related to the injury. This could result in significant financial hardship for the claimant.
What is the role of a professional administrator in a Medicare Set Aside?
A professional administrator can help ensure that the Medicare Set Aside is properly managed and that funds are used only for approved medical expenses. The administrator can also help with reporting requirements and other administrative tasks. It is important to choose an experienced and reputable professional administrator to ensure that the Medicare Set Aside is properly managed.